The Forgotten (2004)reviewed by Benn "Where's the Humanity?" Farrell
"The Forgotten" is about a would-be mother, named Telly, suffering from delusions of raising a
nine year old boy. Everyone in her life, her husband, her therapist, her neighbor says she
miscarried and never had a son named Sam. However, her connection with the child is very strong
and she continues to find questionable evidence her son is NOT a figment of her defense
mechanisms.
Such evidence comes in the form of Ash, ex-New York Ranger and father of Sam's play friend, who
also lost a daughter. Except, Ash doesn't remember ever having a daughter.
Both children were taken on a charter plane, which eventually turned up missing and later
found crashed with no survivors.
Ash finally remembers his child, and now the National Security Agency is looking to nab
Telly, he helps her run off so they can figure out what happened to their kids, and why
NSA wants to speak with them. Of course, Telly say the words "Alien Abduction," which
becomes the storyline from that point on.
Writing out the storyline makes the film sound completely haoky, but honestly, its presented with
much more quality.
Julianne Moore (Boogie Nights) stars as Telly, while Dominic West (Mona Lisa Smile)
plays Ash. Both did fine. In fact, West kind of ate up Moore in their scenes together. Moore
was solid in her unspoken performance. Her role required showing a lot of forethought, which
she did.
Also in the cast was Alfre Woodard (Heart and Souls) as a police detective searching for the
estranged mother, Gary Sinise (Forrest Gump) as Telly's therapist and Anthony Edwards (TV's ER)
as her husband.
The picture is presented as a thriller, but doesn't create much tension with its story or style. There
is more tension create by chase scenes rather than fear of danger.
There are a few holes in the writing also. We never get to know where the kids were supposed to be
going when boarding the charter plane. This would have been a BIG rock for Telly and Ash to look
under, since eventually they believe their children to still be alive. If that's how you--as a
parent--would feel, you would definitely investigate if the flight and destination had anything to
do with the disappearance of the kids. That is basic sense and lost in the picture.
However, the story does examine the charter plane, but the destination wasn't even mentioned. It
made me curious, and the film didn't give us any info about it.
Outside of little holes in the story's background, scenes of running around seem to get old. Too
many chases and not enough substance. The storyline is very simple, and filmmakers had to fill
their contracted time with chase scenes. It's been seen many, many times before.
On a more promising note, even when the movie became about aliens from outer space, it never
focused on the aliens, just the search for the children and the NSA's involvement. It wasn't
about what the aliens looked like. It wasn't about big visual effects models of an alien ship. It
was about Telly refusing to let go of her son.
In the end, that is the clearly stated message of the movie. A mother's bond with her son
is unbreakable, even when the son is taken from her. The movie is kind of a far fetched way
to make such a human statement, but for the most part, the picture was pretty fun to sit
through.
My suggestion is to see "The Forgotten" when you have a chance. It's just THAT much more
original than your typical alien abduction movie. However,
my hunch says this picture will have a fate the same as its title.
Benn - Where's the Humanity? |